Someone Cut a Big Branch Off the Mulberry Tree Her HOA Kept Complaining About, So She Rebuilt It Out of PVC and Wrapped the Whole Tree in Christmas Lights
The branch was gone. For years, members of the homeowners association next door had told her the mulberry tree on her corner lot hung too low. Then someone cut off a large limb that reached out over the street, and she never found out who did it.
Her answer, described in a post TwistedSifter published on Nov. 11, was to build a new branch out of PVC pipe, wrap it in Christmas lights, and wrap the rest of the tree in lights too. She kept them glowing from May until just before Christmas.
A House Just Outside the Lines
The odd part of the fight is that she was never in the HOA. Her corner house faces a street outside the association. The HOA’s neighborhood runs along the side of her property.
When her children were young, they wanted to use the HOA’s pool and playground across the street. She offered to pay HOA fees so they could. The association said no. In her words, the board’s position was simple: “They’re either in the HOA or they’re not.”
That did not stop HOA members from paying attention to her yard. They repeatedly came by to say the mulberry’s branches hung too low and broke the association’s rules.
Why HOA Rules Did Not Apply
HOA rules come from recorded covenants. Cornell Law School’s Legal Information Institute describes a restrictive covenant as a promise in a deed that limits how land can be used, binding the owners of the property it covers. A house that was never part of the association is not bound by its covenants, no matter how close it sits to the entrance.
And whoever cut the branch, if it was done from or on her property without permission, crossed a line of its own. Entering someone’s land without consent is trespass, and cutting someone else’s tree can carry its own damages in many states. She was never able to identify who cut it.
A Tree Her Children Still Pick From
She planted the mulberry herself on the corner of her property. Her children, now in their 20s, still gather its berries every spring.
Mulberries are fast, tough yard trees. The U.S. Forest Service’s Silvics of North America describes red mulberry as a small to medium tree whose sweet fruit is eaten by people, birds and other wildlife. A spreading crown is part of the appeal, and also, in a neighborhood obsessed with clearance over the street, part of the problem.
PVC, Rope and a Lot of Lights
The replacement branch was not subtle. She built it from PVC, wrapped it in Christmas lights, and propped it up with old branches and rope. Then she lit up the whole tree.
HOA members came by to ask her to take the lights down, saying she was hurting property values. She told them to back off. The HOA’s letters went into the trash. She warned them that if she were in the HOA, they would see her kids swimming in the pool. The association never touched the lights.
Lights on a tree for months at a time do call for some care. The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission’s holiday safety guidance urges people to use lights rated for outdoor use and check strings for frayed wires before hanging them.
A Familiar Kind of Defiance
TwistedSifter’s write-up said the HOA got what it deserved, while noting that cutting the branch would have been more understandable if it had blocked the street or sidewalk. The post does not say whether it did.
Defiant answers to HOA complaints have a following on this site. One homeowner answered an order to remove her tree swing with a yard full of decorations, and a Florida homeowner fought her association over fence rules.
The mulberry is still standing, still fruiting, and for a good part of the year, still glowing.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Alena Hroncová – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons
