Two goats stand close together outdoors

Investigators Say a Marathon County Man Admitted Killing His Neighbor’s Four Goats Over the Fence Between Their Land. He Now Faces 4 Felony Counts.

Four goats were hurt or killed on a Marathon County, Wisconsin property in October 2024, and for almost two years nobody was charged. Now a 34-year-old neighbor, Eric Seelow, faces four felony counts of animal mistreatment, after an investigator says he admitted to the killings and blamed the fence between the two properties.

Seelow appeared in court on Wednesday, Nov. 18, according to WSAW in Wausau. Along with the four felonies, he is charged with one misdemeanor count of criminal damage to property, and he pleaded not guilty to the misdemeanor.

A Report in October 2024, Then a Cold Case

The goats’ owner reported on Oct. 14, 2024, that the animals had been injured, WSAW reported. A sheriff’s deputy who came out found one goat dead and two wounded. Later, the owner found a fourth goat dead.

The investigation went inactive for lack of evidence. It stayed that way until August 2026, when an investigator spoke with Seelow. According to the station’s account of the case, Seelow admitted shooting one of the goats and running over the other three with a four-wheeler.

The reason he gave, according to the report, was the fence. Seelow said he believed the owner had not properly maintained the fence between their properties.

The investigator sent the case to the Marathon County District Attorney’s Office after the goats’ owner asked for charges to be filed. The district attorney’s office handles criminal prosecutions in the county.

What the Judge Ordered

Circuit Court Judge Suzanne O’Neill set a $1,000 signature bond, WSAW reported. The conditions bar Seelow from contacting the goats’ owner, from possessing weapons and from having contact with animals that are not his own.

A pre-trial hearing is scheduled for February. Charges are accusations, and Seelow is presumed innocent unless proven guilty. Case details for Wisconsin circuit courts are posted on the state’s public Wisconsin Circuit Court Access site.

The animal mistreatment counts fall under Wisconsin’s crimes against animals chapter, Chapter 951 of the state statutes, which covers mistreating animals and sets out the penalties.

What Wisconsin Law Says About the Fence Between Neighbors

Fences between neighbors with livestock are not just a matter of manners in Wisconsin. Chapter 90 of the Wisconsin statutes sets rules for partition fences on land used for farming or grazing.

Under section 90.03, occupants of adjoining land used for farming or grazing must “keep and maintain partition fences between their own and the adjoining premises in equal shares.” The law says those fences are to be kept in good repair through the year unless both sides agree otherwise.

The same chapter gives local officials a role. Town supervisors, city alderpersons and village trustees serve as fence viewers, who can be called on to divide fence duties when neighbors cannot agree. Under section 90.05, a division of the fence can be set in writing by the owners or by fence viewers and recorded with the town clerk.

The statute also deals with animals that cross over. Under section 90.04, an owner who fails to keep up a lawful partition fence cannot recover damages when a neighbor’s animals trespass. Building a fence, though, does not protect owners of swine, horses, sheep or goats from liability for damage their animals cause to the neighbor’s enclosed land.

None of that allows a neighbor to harm animals over a fence dispute. The law lays out a process, through fence viewers, written agreements and civil claims, for settling who owes what.

A Fence Fight That Went Far Past the Fence

Disputes over shared fences are common on this site’s pages, from neighbors who want the family next door to let goats graze right up to the fence line to arguments over who pays for repairs. Most end with a survey, a bill or a court date over money.

This case is headed to court for a different reason. The fence is the motive investigators say Seelow gave, and the four goats are the reason he is facing felony charges. The case returns to court for the pre-trial hearing in February.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Similar Posts