A wooden board fence beside a residential yard

A Neighbor Building Next Door Took a Lake Family’s Fence to the Zoning Board Over His View, Then Ran a Chainsaw at 7 a.m. and Filmed Their Daughter Raking the Lake

A lakeside family thought the fight was over once their fence met the rules. The man building a house next door had complained to the zoning board, the family had lost a variance, and they had cut the fence down to a height the board approved.

He was still not satisfied. What followed, as TwistedSifter reported on Nov. 12, was a chainsaw started at odd hours, a threat aimed at the whole fence, and a camera pointed at the family’s adult daughter while she raked out the lake.

From Six Feet to Four

The family had put up a six-foot privacy fence that turned out to exceed the local height limit. They applied for a variance, and it was denied. So they took out the over-height section and installed a four-foot fence that the zoning board signed off on.

Limits like that are common. Portsmouth, New Hampshire, caps front-yard fences at 4 feet and side and rear fences at 6 feet. In Fairfax County, Virginia, a front-yard fence generally cannot exceed four feet, and going up to six takes a special permit approved by the Board of Zoning Appeals. The family’s town was not named, but the process they went through follows the same pattern: a limit, a request for an exception, and a board that says yes or no.

A Complaint About a Basement Window

The neighbor who filed the complaint said the fence blocked his view of the lake from a basement window. The family says the fence blocks nothing.

A view alone rarely carries legal weight. Absent a specific ordinance or agreement, there is no legal right to a view in the United States, according to California law firm Stimmel, Stimmel & Roeser. The same firm notes that zoning rules are often strictly enforced, which is why a height limit can do what a view complaint cannot.

Nolo’s editors make the same point from the other side: in cities without a view ordinance, the rules that can matter are local ones such as fence height limits. That is the route the neighbor used. The family complied, and the four-foot fence that stands now is the one the board approved.

The Chainsaw and the Camera

After the fence came down to four feet, the neighbor told the husband he would run a chainsaw at annoying hours until the entire fence was gone. According to the family, he kept within the local noise limits while doing it.

He would start the saw around 7 a.m., run it for a few minutes, then put it back in his truck. He did the same around 9 to 9:30 p.m., again and again. The neighbor on the family’s other side ended up in a long shouting match with him.

Then the family caught him recording their adult daughter as she raked out the lake. She reported it to the state police and has a report number.

A Family That Locks Its Doors

The family has chosen not to retaliate, because they consider him dangerous. The woman who shared the story said she now locks her doors during the day, and that his behavior grew worse over the summer.

His wife has not stepped in. According to the family, she said she was supposed to honor him, and she rarely visits the property after he yelled at her for waving to the homeowner.

TwistedSifter’s writer suggested the man would eventually tire himself out. As of the report, nothing had been resolved. The fence was legal, the police report was on file, and the house next door was still going up.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Estormiz – CC0/Wikimedia Commons

Similar Posts