Pittsburgh Crews Tore Out John Harris’s Pool, Deck, Shed and Fence for Retaining Walls, and the City Offered $24,000 Against His $63,000 Estimate

A pool, a deck, a shed, a fence and the steps down to the yard all came out when Pittsburgh crews built two retaining walls to steady a sliding road beside John Harris’s Spring Garden home. The city has since offered $24,000 to settle his property claim, while Harris holds a $63,000 estimate to put the yard back together. He rejected the offer and sued, and WPXI reported on Oct. 19 that the city says it is preparing a new one.

As of Nov. 6, no newer offer had turned up in published coverage, so the $24,000 figure remains the only one on the record.

What Came Out of the Yard to Make Room for the Walls

According to WPXI’s investigation by Rick Earle, the work began about four years ago. The road above and below the Harris home had begun to slide, and city crews built two retaining walls to stabilize it. Getting the walls in meant removing the pool, deck, shed, fence and steps. Crews also damaged the home’s siding, and without the steps Harris lost access to the yard.

The same report, which was carried by Yahoo News, says Harris and his late wife had a written agreement with the city’s legal department before construction began. Under it, everything removed was supposed to be replaced or repaired. “It’s all in writing and signed off by their legal department,” Harris said.

Spring Garden sits in a valley on Pittsburgh’s North Side, with Spring Garden Avenue running along the valley floor between the hilltop neighborhoods of Spring Hill and Troy Hill, according to the neighborhood’s encyclopedia entry. The WPXI report does not say which slide prompted the walls beside the Harris home.

The scale of what disappeared is easy to underestimate from a list. A pool and a deck are the large structures, but a fence and a shed define how a backyard is used, and the steps were the only way down to it. Without them, according to the report, Harris lost access to the yard from the house, and the estimate he obtained covers landscaping repairs as well as the rebuilt structures.

The $24,000 Offer Against a $63,000 Estimate

The gap is the heart of the dispute. WPXI reported that the city first offered $24,000 to resolve the property damage claims. Harris then obtained a $63,000 estimate covering the siding, the landscaping, and the rebuilding of the pool, shed, fence, deck and steps.

He turned the offer down. “No, not at all. It was a slap in the face,” Harris said when asked about it. The difference between the two numbers is $39,000, and the estimate is one figure, not a court finding or an appraisal agreed to by both sides.

After delays, Harris hired attorneys and sued the city. WPXI did not report a court date or a ruling, and it did not say what the city has argued in the case. The report does not include a direct on-record statement from the city beyond its confirmation that it is reviewing the matter.

That confirmation came after inquiries and documentation were sent to the mayor’s office. City officials told the station they are reviewing the claim and preparing a new settlement offer. The station did not report an amount or terms for that offer, and no later coverage of it has appeared.

A Councilwoman’s Widower and the Question of Politics

Harris is the husband of the late Darlene Harris, who served on Pittsburgh City Council from 2006 to 2019 and died earlier this year, according to WPXI. Mayor Corey O’Connor, in a statement published March 6, 2026, called her a longtime advocate, School Board director and Council member who never forgot her working-class roots, and said her public service spanned more than 40 years.

WESA reported that Darlene Harris died March 6, 2026, after being elected in 2006 to represent the North Side’s District 1. She served as council president from 2010 to 2014 and was known for clashes with former Mayor Bill Peduto and other council members. She lost the seat to Bobby Wilson, the current representative. She was born in Brighton Heights and spent most of her life in Spring Hill, a neighborhood next to Spring Garden.

Harris believes her outspoken years on council may explain why his claim has dragged. Harris said part of it is political. WPXI presented that as his belief, not an established fact, and the report carried no city response to that suggestion.

For a homeowner, the case turns on a plain question: what a city owes when public work takes a private yard apart. Here, the answer on paper is a signed agreement to replace or repair what was removed. In practice, the question is now whether the next offer comes closer to $63,000 than the first one did, and whether a lawsuit already filed has to run its course.

Several details are still missing from the public record. WPXI did not report the date of the written agreement, the name of the city official who signed it, or the exact wording of what the city promised to restore. It also did not say whether the $24,000 was meant to cover all of the items on the list or only some of them. Those answers are likely to matter if the lawsuit moves forward.

Until the city puts a new number in writing, Harris has a yard without its steps, pool, deck, shed or fence, a house with damaged siding, and an estimate that is more than two and a half times the city’s opening offer.

Get stories like this by email. Sign up for The Parent Diaries Letter.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Im Fokus – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons