A wooden privacy fence along the edge of a residential backyard

An HOA Agreed to Pay $200,000 After Refusing a De Pere Family a Backyard Fence for Their Kids, and Now 55 Neighbors Who Haven’t Paid Their Share Are Being Sued

Lisa and Michael Newman wanted a fence so their five children could play in the backyard of their De Pere, Wisconsin, home without wandering off. Their homeowners association said no, the family went to federal court, and the association ended up agreeing to pay them $200,000. Now, more than two years after that settlement, the fight has a second lawsuit, and this one names the neighbors.

Each member of the Nazcr Trac subdivision’s association was supposed to chip in $1,350 toward the settlement. According to the Newmans’ attorney, 55 homeowners still owe their share, Green Bay station NBC 26 reported on Nov. 13. This fall, the family filed a new suit against the association and the homeowners who have not paid.

A Covenant That Said No Fences of Any Kind

All five of the Newman children have been diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder, and they also have physical medical needs, NBC 26 and sister station TMJ4 reported in January 2025. Lisa Newman said she wanted a fence so the kids could be outside without running off and getting lost.

The couple asked the association’s board for permission in 2019. The board pointed to a covenant on the subdivision’s 2001 plat map: “No fences of any kind shall be allowed.” Board minutes from April 2021 said the Newmans were “well aware” of the rule when they bought the house.

Lisa Newman told the station the board simply wanted to fight the family on it.

A Federal Judge Let the Fence Go Up

With help from Disability Rights Wisconsin, the family sued in federal court for the Eastern District of Wisconsin in 2021, arguing the denial violated federal fair housing law, a case the Wisconsin Law Journal covered in May 2022. On May 3, 2022, District Judge William Griesbach granted the family a preliminary injunction in Newman v. Nazcr Trac Property Owners Association, and the fence was built.

The federal Fair Housing Act generally requires housing providers, including many homeowners associations, to allow reasonable changes and exceptions to rules when a person with a disability needs them, according to joint guidance from the federal Department of Housing and Urban Development and the Justice Department.

In August 2024, a settlement required the association to pay the Newmans $200,000, with the cost split among members at $1,350 each. Homeowners later received letters asking for the money “to avoid becoming defendants in a new legal action,” the stations reported at the time.

Neighbors Who Say They Had No Say

Many paid. NBC 26 reported that 69 homeowners settled after the original case. Others refused, and some told the station in early 2025 that they did not believe they were legally required to pay.

“There’s an outstanding judgment,” attorney Victoria Davis Dávila, who represents the Newmans, told NBC 26. She said the homeowners who still owe had the chance to pay and chose not to, and that if the money is not paid, the association’s membership as a whole could potentially be held liable.

Some residents said they did not know about the dispute until the settlement was announced, and one told the station that homeowners had “zero input” and “zero involvement” in it. Another, who already paid, said the uncertainty has him thinking about moving because no one knows what will happen next.

What Comes Next in De Pere

Former board members declined to comment, NBC 26 reported. Neighbors said the association was looking for a lawyer, and a response to the new lawsuit was due the week the story aired.

Davis Dávila said the family wants the matter finished. “The Newmans want just as bad as anybody else to put this behind them,” she said.

Fence rules have pulled other homeowners into fights this fall, including Sun City Center neighbors ordered to tear out fences their HOA had approved and a Florida homeowner whose HOA officer photographed the mesh on her dog fence.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: ParentingPatch – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wikimedia Commons

Similar Posts