Des Moines Gardener Allison Stuart Tore Out Her Curbside Vegetable Beds After the City Cited Her, and More Than 860 People Signed Her Petition
Before Halloween, Allison Stuart took apart the vegetable beds she had grown on the city-owned strip between her sidewalk and the curb in Des Moines, Iowa, more than a week ahead of a Nov. 2 deadline set by the city, Civil Eats reported. The city had cited her in June. More than 860 people signed her online petition asking Des Moines to let residents grow food there.
Fifteen Years of Gardening, Then a Citation
Stuart has gardened for about 15 years around her 1898 house, according to Civil Eats. About two years ago a storm toppled a tree near the street, opening an 11-foot-wide patch of sun. She invited neighbors to grow vegetables there, including nearby families who came to Iowa from Myanmar and Afghanistan.
The city opened a case against the garden on May 15, when it had three scrap-wood beds with seedlings coming up. On June 4 it cited her and ordered the beds removed. Stuart told Civil Eats that would have killed the young plants. She said she did not know about the rule. Axios Des Moines reported that the beds held tomatoes, broccoli, onions and herbs, and that continued noncompliance could bring abatement costs and, if pursued as a municipal infraction, a civil penalty of up to $750.
The Petition and the Reprieve
Stuart started an online petition on Change.org asking Des Moines and West Des Moines officials to protect homeowners’ right to garden on property easements. Civil Eats put the signature count above 860, and the petition page lists 870 verified signatures.
At an Aug. 19 hearing, Stuart and the city agreed she could keep growing through the season, with removal required by Nov. 2. Axios Des Moines reported that she had appealed a nuisance violation over three vegetable beds and that the deal could ultimately save the garden while the city’s Food Sustainability Advisory Committee reviews the rules. She pulled the garden out before the deadline.
The City’s Side
City Engineer Steve Naber told Civil Eats that growing anything other than grass, natural plants and city-planted trees in the right-of-way has never been legal. A June 2025 ordinance made the ban on edible plants explicit, he said, while allowing decorative plantings up to 36 inches tall. Naber cited visibility at intersections, utility and emergency access, and hazards for older residents across the city’s roughly 900 miles of streets.
Older city paperwork points the same way on permission. A 2004 ordinance, No. 14,366, requires a garden lease for anyone who wants to plant flowers, plants or shrubs in a permanent structure on city right-of-way, and says a lease shall be denied if the City Engineer finds the planting likely to create a danger or nuisance.
The city does run a program for flowers. Its Neighborhood Flower Program lets volunteers plant city-grown annuals on right-of-ways, medians, street corners and parkways, as long as they commit to planting, watering and maintaining them for the year.
Where the Rules Could Go Next
The question is not settled. Civil Eats reported that the City Council referred food gardens in rights-of-way to the Food Sustainability Advisory Committee, with no timeline for a decision, and that the city is not bound by the committee’s recommendations. In 2024 the council unanimously paused enforcement of these citations while a task force reviewed a recommendation to allow more fruit and vegetables in such spaces, Axios reported. That task force had recommended in 2021 that the city allow right-of-way food crops.
Kathy Byrnes, who runs Birds & Bees Urban Farm, told the council that the 2025 change went largely unnoticed and was adopted without discussion of what it would mean for food growing.
What Stuart Plans for Spring
Stuart told Civil Eats she plans to garden next year on a sidewalk-side spot she owns, and she may plant flowers in the right-of-way in spring.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
