A trimmed green hedge growing along the edge of a yard

A Neighbor Cut Down a Family’s Privacy Plants Twice, Once at 2 a.m. The Boundary Marking Showed His Own Fence Was 11 Feet Over Their Line.

A week after a family planted privacy shrubs that cost thousands of dollars, the plants were chopped down, and the neighbor next door said they had been on his side of the line. The family replanted under the installer’s warranty, then caught the same neighbor cutting the new shrubs at 2 a.m. and called police. When the neighbor hired a professional to mark the boundary, the markers showed his own fence sat 11 feet over the family’s property line, according to TwistedSifter’s retelling.

The account comes from a post by a member of the family and has not been independently verified. It does not name the town or say when it happened, so the details below are the family’s version as TwistedSifter reported it.

A Week After Planting, the Shrubs Were Gone

The family had moved into a neighborhood where the homes sit close together. They did not want the neighbors looking into their kitchen, so they planted a row of privacy shrubs, a purchase TwistedSifter says ran to thousands of dollars.

About a week later, the plants had been cut down. The father confronted the neighbor, who said the shrubs stood on his property line and that he had every right to remove them. He also warned that he would report the family to the authorities if anything crossed onto his land again, the account says.

The family says the planting was on their own side. Rather than argue over where the line ran, the father called the company that had installed the shrubs.

The Replant and the 2 A.M. Visit

Because the plants were under warranty, the installer agreed to put them back the following week at no charge.

Then, according to the account, the family caught the neighbor cutting the new plants down at 2 a.m. They called the police over the damage to their property. After a conversation with the neighbor, the neighbor hired a professional to mark the property line, and the father agreed to it.

Neighbors who fight over a line sometimes find, as in a decade-long feud that ended when a survey showed both sides were wrong, that a survey is what finally settles it.

Orange Tape in the Neighbor’s Yard

When the surveyor finished, orange survey tape showed up in the neighbor’s yard. The marked line placed his fence about 11 feet over the family’s property line, TwistedSifter reports. The shrubs he had twice cut down had never been on his land.

The neighbor took the fence down. With it went about a quarter of the backyard he had been treating as his own.

Within a month, the family had its privacy back. The neighbor, by the account, paid almost $10,000 for the damage to the plants and the replanting.

A similar reversal turned up in a homeowner’s account of a rock garden that spilled across the line, another case where a survey, not a feeling, decided who owned the ground.

What Surveyors and Property Law Say About Plants on the Line

Property lines are invisible, which is why disputes like this start so easily. FindLaw says boundaries are defined in deeds, plat maps and county records, and that they often differ from where fences or landscaping actually sit. A licensed land surveyor can interpret those documents and mark the lines, FindLaw notes.

This Old House calls a licensed surveyor the most accurate way to find a property line and says the service can run "several hundred dollars or more," depending on the size and location of the property. It recommends one for persistent boundary disputes and for projects near the edge of a yard, such as fencing or landscaping. The magazine also warns against trusting a fence as the boundary, and it describes a homeowner who did and had five mature trees cut on a neighbor’s land.

On fences, Justia says a fence built partly on a neighbor’s land is an encroachment, and it names a survey as the tool that often resolves the problem. Justia also warns that long-standing encroachments can become harder to challenge over time. That is a reason owners may want to learn where the line runs before years go by.

On plants specifically, LegalMatch says an owner may trim overhanging branches and cut interfering roots when needed to prevent damage, but that the owner pays for the work and can be liable if the plant is irreparably harmed. It recommends talking with the neighbor first, and checking a plat map or a survey to learn which property a plant sits in.

In this case, the family says its shrubs sat inside its own line, and the survey placed the neighbor’s fence well past it. By the account, the warranty replant did not stop the neighbor from cutting a second time.

What the Family Got Back

The family got its privacy planting back where it had put it, and the fence at the center of the argument came down. The account does not say whether the two households ever spoke again, or whether the family took any further legal step.

Planting near a fence line is the situation the surveyors and law sites above describe. A survey before the first shrub goes in is the step they recommend, and the several hundred dollars it can cost is small next to thousands of dollars of plants.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: IsouM – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Hedge_in_Brussels.jpg)

Similar Posts