A wooden privacy fence along the edge of a residential backyard

A Family Paid a Surveyor Before Replacing Their Falling-Apart Backyard Fences. The Neighbor Says They Can’t, Because Her Dog Has Always Roamed Both Yards.

The backyard came with a creek, a strip of woods and a jumble of old fences. A young family who bought the house about six months ago describes the fencing as a “hodgepodge of different types of fences that were falling apart.” With small children at home and running water at the back of the lot, they wanted one uniform fence, and they hired a surveyor to make sure it went exactly on their line.

The older woman next door had other plans. According to the family’s post, which TwistedSifter wrote up on Nov. 8, she told them they were not allowed to build it.

A Dog That Had the Run of Two Yards

Her reason had nothing to do with the property line. Under the previous owners, her dog had roamed freely through both backyards for years. A fence would end that.

The family said the fence was about their children’s safety and “had nothing to do with her.” The neighborhood has no homeowners association, so there was no board to approve or block the plan, only the town’s ordinary rules for fences.

The neighbor did not let it go. She called the family selfish and an “animal hater,” and, by their account, tried to rally other neighbors against the fence. For a family still unpacking and learning the names on the street, that kind of campaign can sting more than the fence itself costs.

What the Survey Settles

The family’s decision to pay for a survey before building is the step that usually decides fights like this one. Old fences, especially a patchwork put up by different owners over the years, often do not sit on the true boundary. Some lean into one yard, some into the other, and neighbors grow used to treating the fence as the line even when it is not.

A fresh survey replaces that guesswork with marked corners. Building on the surveyed line means the new fence will sit on the family’s own land, which leaves the neighbor with no claim that it takes anything from her yard. Her objection is not about where the fence goes. It is about the fact that it goes up at all.

Long Use Is Not the Same as a Right

The idea that something done for years becomes a right does exist in property law, but not the way the neighbor framed it. Cornell Law School’s Legal Information Institute explains that a prescriptive easement can arise when someone openly and continuously uses another person’s land for a period set by state law, without permission. Related doctrine on adverse possession can, in rare cases, transfer ownership after long occupation.

Both doctrines are about people using land in specific ways, such as a path or a driveway, and both usually fail when the use happened with the owner’s permission. A neighbor’s dog wandering between friendly backyards is not the kind of use courts protect. The basic rule of real property ownership still applies: owners decide what goes on their land, within local codes.

Why a Fence Matters With Kids and a Creek

For the family, the case for the fence is simple. A creek at the back of the yard is a drowning risk for small children, and a fence keeps them in.

A fence also keeps animals out. The American Veterinary Medical Association’s dog bite prevention guidance notes that children are the most common victims of dog bites, and urges parents never to leave young children alone with a dog, even a familiar one. A neighbor’s dog with free access to a yard where toddlers play is exactly the situation that advice is about.

Readers Sided With the Family

Commenters on the post were nearly unanimous that the family was in the right. TwistedSifter’s write-up called the dog’s past access “completely irrelevant” and noted that the family had already done the most important thing by getting a survey.

Fence fights keep turning ugly. An Oregon homeowner’s neighbor climbed the fence and cut down 12 arborvitae, and one gardener said her neighbor’s loose dogs turned her backyard garden into a daily battleground.

The post did not say whether the fence has gone up. The family still has its survey, its plan and the law on its side, and a neighbor who sees a fence on her neighbors’ land as something taken from her dog.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Similar Posts