The Seller Next Door Says Brittany Ellerbe’s Petersburg Backyard Isn’t Hers, and Part of Her Family’s Fence Is Already Gone
When Brittany Ellerbe and her husband bought a nearly 100-year-old house on South Dunlop Street in Petersburg, Virginia, in 2025, the backyard was gravel. They turned it into grass, put up a privacy fence for their two toddlers, and grew flowers, zucchini, squash and bush beans. Now the seller of the house behind them says the backyard was never theirs.
Part of the family’s fence has already come down, and the dispute is in court, Richmond station WWBT (NBC12) reported on Oct. 27. A Petersburg judge granted an injunction and a temporary restraining order in early October, and that order was set to last until Nov. 19.
A Realtor, Then a Truck Full of Workers
The trouble started about a year after the purchase. According to WWBT, a realtor working for the former owner of the home on Wilcox Street, which backs up to the Ellerbes’ lot, told the couple their back steps sat on the Wilcox Street owner’s land and the backyard wasn’t theirs. He said part of their fence had to come down so the sale of that house could close.
Nothing happened for months. Then the seller showed up with a truck of workers, the station reported. Ellerbe said that at that point she had seen no survey, no deed and no letter from a lawyer.
Those came later. An attorney’s letter and a land survey arrived, and part of the Ellerbes’ fence was taken down and used to line another section of the neighboring property, according to the report. Ellerbe said that before the fence was moved, the yard held their flowers and vegetable plants.
The station put her words at the top of its report: “There’s no survey.”
An 1853 Plat and a 1917 Deed
The couple hired a lawyer. In early October, a judge granted the injunction and temporary restraining order, and the family is waiting on another court date in November, WWBT reported.
The judge reportedly said the boundary’s location wasn’t certain, that some records were missing, and that the Ellerbes’ survey had not been recorded. Ellerbe pointed to an 1853 plat and a 1917 deed as the history of her home, and said no survey is on file.
A spokesperson for Petersburg’s assessor’s office told the station that “this appears to be a legal matter between the two property owners.” WWBT left contact information at the Wilcox Street home and had not heard back when it published.
What Virginia Tells Buyers About Lot Lines
Ellerbe said she and her husband, as first-time buyers, didn’t understand how much a land survey mattered. Virginia doesn’t require one for a home sale, but the state does warn buyers.
Under the Virginia Residential Property Disclosure Act, sellers give buyers a set of notices, which the Virginia Department of Professional and Occupational Regulation publishes on its residential property disclosures page. One of them says the owner “makes no representation with respect to current lot lines,” and advises buyers to do their own due diligence, “including obtaining a property survey.” The same language appears on the state’s official disclosure statement form.
The act itself is listed in the Virginia Code’s table of popular names, and WWBT cited it directly in its report. Ellerbe said she believes the city “has to keep a more watchful eye,” and that realtors “need to help their clients.”
How Fence Fights Usually End
Boundary and fence disagreements between neighbors in Virginia are generally civil matters. Virginia Tech’s Jennifer Friedel, who wrote the extension guide Boundaries of Virginia Fence Law, notes that most fence disputes are handled in circuit court and that mediation is an option. She recommends keeping records of notices, costs and dates, since they can serve as evidence.
Fence-line fights have come up on this site before. In one case, a survey showed two feuding neighbors had both been wrong about where their fence belonged. In another, a new neighbor roped off a trail beside a rural yard and claimed the path as his.
For the Ellerbes, the next step is the November court date. The restraining order was set to run through Nov. 19, according to the station, and the judge has said the boundary’s location isn’t yet certain.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Infrogmation of New Orleans – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons
