The Owner of a Villages Home Has Died, and Its Overgrown Yard Now Faces Fines of $50 a Day
Nobody has been answering for the villa at 2726 Moncayo Ave. Its owner, Helene Scharaldi, has died, and the emergency contact numbers on file no longer work. Meanwhile, the yard has kept growing.
On Friday, supervisors for Community Development District 2 in The Villages, Florida, ordered the property’s landscaping fixed within seven days and its broken fence repaired within 30, or fines will follow, Villages-News.com reported on Nov. 15. If the violations continue, the property faces $250 each time it has to be maintained, plus $50 a day.
Grass, Weeds and Bushes Growing Into the Eaves
The case began with a complaint. CDD 2 received a complaint about unkempt landscaping at the home in Villa Del Canto on Aug. 27, according to the report. When an inspector went out, the list was long: overgrown grass and weeds, bushes growing into the eaves, rogue vines and a broken fence.
Shannon Boyd, assistant director of community standards, provided the owner information at the public hearing, Villages-News reported. With the owner gone and the listed contacts dead ends, the district has had no one to call.
The Department of Housing and Urban Development holds the mortgage on the property and was notified of the violations, according to the report.
Why a District Can Fine a Yard
In The Villages, deed compliance cases like this one are handled by the community development districts themselves.
Florida law gives those districts the power, under narrow conditions. The state’s statute on community development district powers lets a district adopt rules to enforce certain deed restrictions covering property inside its boundaries, as long as no homeowners association holds those enforcement powers. The restrictions it can enforce are limited to ones governing external appearance or use, and the district may impose fines that can be enforced through court injunctions.
The statute sets other conditions too. For residential districts, a majority of the board must be elected by qualified voters, fewer than 25% of residential units can be in a homeowners association, and the developer must provide a recorded written agreement. Once a district adopts deed-restriction rules, it has 60 days to record a notice of that adoption.
Deed restrictions are the backbone of that system. Cornell Law School’s Legal Information Institute describes a restrictive covenant as a clause in a deed or other real estate transfer that limits what the new owner can do with the land, which neighboring owners may be able to enforce.
The Villages’ district government says on its website that Florida law bars its boards of supervisors from discussing deed compliance cases with residents. Concerns instead go to the Community Standards Department through a deed-violation request form or by email to [email protected]. Other non-emergency problems can be reported through the district’s Report It app, which runs on SeeClickFix, and the site notes that report descriptions are public.
A Busy Year for Complaints
The Moncayo Avenue villa is one case among many. Over the past year, CDD 2 has handled 134 deed restriction complaints, issued 25 written violations and held eight public hearings, according to Villages-News.
Getting a property into compliance can take a long time. Supervisor Jim Cipollone said the process “takes two or three years,” the report said.
What a Kept Florida Yard Looks Like
For the homes on either side of an empty, overgrown villa, the fix is overdue. The University of Florida’s Florida-Friendly Landscaping program builds its advice for homeowners around nine principles, starting with “right plant, right place” and including watering efficiently, fertilizing appropriately, mulching, managing yard pests responsibly and recycling yard waste.
A bush growing into the eaves is the opposite of right plant, right place. Until someone takes responsibility for the villa, the order from CDD 2 means the yard will be cut back one way or another, and the bill will follow the property.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: User:Vmenkov – CC BY-SA 3.0/Wikimedia Commons
