Neighbors in Etobicoke Spent Years Saving a White Fir. It Came Down the Day After the Lot Sold, Under Removal Permits Toronto Says It Never Issued.
For more than five decades, Randy McWatters watched a white fir grow above a two-bedroom bungalow on Fortieth Street in Toronto’s Long Branch neighbourhood. When a plan to split the lot threatened it, he and other neighbours helped fight to save it, and they won.
On Oct. 24, one day after the property changed hands, the fir and three other trees were cut down without permits, CBC Toronto reported. Removal permits on City of Toronto letterhead had been posted at the house. The city says it never issued them.
The tree the neighbours already saved once
The fight over the fir at 65 Fortieth St. goes back years. In 2018, the previous owner applied to sever the lot and build two new homes. The committee of adjustment approved the plan despite objections from the city’s urban forestry department, according to CBC’s report.
The city appealed to the Toronto Local Appeal Body, and in 2022 the body sided with the city, because the plan required removing a healthy tree. Neighbour Sherry McCutcheon described the fir to CBC as the “epitome of the perfect tree.”
Permits nobody at city hall signed
The property was bought by a company directed by Ron Sheinin and Rohan Sadana, co-founders of the developer Modcity, CBC reported. Photos show apparent removal permits for three trees posted at the property on city letterhead. The city says it did not issue them.
Neighbours said they saw Sheinin and Sadana at the property while the trees came down, and a car with a Modcity vanity plate was parked across the street. Its registered owner is a numbered company where Sheinin is president and sole director, according to CBC.
Local councillor Amber Morley said that if the documents were forged, that would be a crime and must be fully investigated. Modcity denies wrongdoing. Sadana wrote that the company strongly disputes the allegations, and neither co-founder answered detailed questions, including whether they posted the permits or authorized the cutting.
A pattern of complaints
This isn’t the first time neighbours have accused the company of cutting trees. In April, CBC reported that neighbours on Kirknewton Road in Dufferin-Eglinton watched a Modcity executive and a worker take down trees with a chainsaw starting around 11 p.m., at a house whose sale hadn’t yet closed. Earlier that month, neighbours on Glenrose Avenue said three mature trees were removed from a vacant home, and that a worker claimed to have permits the city says were never issued, according to that report. Sadana said Modcity had nothing to do with the Glenrose removals.
As of early September, the city had 10 open investigations related to Modcity, and the company faces four tree bylaw charges now before the courts. In Toronto, a permit is required to remove a tree over 30 centimetres in diameter, and fines for cutting without one can reach $100,000 per offence.
Why fines may not be enough
Danijela Puric-Mladenovic, a University of Toronto forestry assistant professor, told CBC that bylaws and fines are weak deterrents. Part of the problem is legal: provincial law prevents the city from denying a building permit over tree bylaw violations. The city asked the province last year to change that, and the Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing hadn’t responded to CBC.
What a neighbourhood loses with a tree like this is hard to replace quickly. The U.S. Forest Service notes that urban trees provide shade, cut noise and help conserve energy, and the Arbor Day Foundation says shaded surfaces can be 20 to 45 degrees cooler than unshaded ones. A seedling planted today will take decades to do what the fir did over the bungalow.
For McWatters and McCutcheon, the tree they saved at the appeal body is gone. The city is investigating whether bylaws were broken, and whether the permits posted on the lawn were fakes.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Agnieszka Kwiecień, Nova – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons
