A dog looking through a gap in a wooden backyard fence on a sunny day

A Homeowner Says His Elderly Neighbor’s One-Day Fence Sits Several Feet Into His Yard, and She Asked Him to Just Live With It

The request was simple: leave the fence where it is, because a survey is expensive. A Southern California homeowner told TwistedSifter that his elderly neighbor put that question to him after a contractor built her new fence in a single day. He says he turned her down, and he plans to order a survey to find out whether the fence sits several feet onto his land.

A Fence Built in One Day While He Was at Work

According to the TwistedSifter write-up, the two neighbors get along and both own hillside homes worth about $1 million. She wanted to fence her yard to keep out high school students who had been trespassing. He told her to go ahead and asked only that the fence stay on her side of the line.

While he was at work, the contractor finished the job in one day. The homeowner believes the fence now stands several feet south of the sewer grates, which would put it on his property. He says his title records show the two lots share an easement that was split between them, and he had assumed the fence would go on the north side of the grate.

“Just Live With It”

When he raised the concern, the neighbor brushed it off and did not think the fence was misplaced. He told her he would hire a survey, and said a few inches of error would not bother him. If the survey showed the fence several feet inside his lot, he would ask her to move it.

That surprised and annoyed her, the write-up says. She asked whether he would simply accept the fence, since a survey and any relocation would cost money. He refused. He said he should not have to “donate land” he pays for because of her error. He pointed to the small size of his yard and the high price of land in the area, and said she should have had a survey done before building.

What a Survey Would Actually Settle

Only a licensed professional can answer the question the two neighbors disagree on. The California Board for Professional Engineers, Land Surveyors, and Geologists says it is unlawful to do or offer land surveying without a license, and that licensed surveyors retrace property lines, determine boundary discrepancies and set the monuments that mark property corners. The board also notes that a person who disagrees with a surveyor’s work can pay another licensed professional to review it.

The California Land Surveyors Association adds that a surveyor does not decide what a person owns. The owner supplies the legal description or title report, and the surveyor locates it on the ground. Encroachments and easements can be shown if the owner asks and provides a current title report. Existing fences can help a surveyor, and the association says neighbors who cooperate can settle a hard boundary with a boundary line agreement.

FindLaw’s guide to boundary disputes says surveys typically start around $500, that the owner who orders one usually pays first, and that a judge can reassign the cost if the dispute reaches court. It also warns that even a fence a few inches over the line can cause trouble later, including a title company refusing to insure a sale.

Who Pays for a Fence Between Two Yards

California’s Civil Code section 841 makes adjoining owners presumptively share the cost of a fence that divides their properties, and requires 30 days’ written notice before one neighbor incurs those costs. The statute does not say how a fence built entirely on the other owner’s land is treated, and it does not mention surveys, so it does not answer the question here.

Similar fights have played out on this site before. One family was told to pay $2,000 to tie into a neighbor’s fence even as survey caps suggested a corner sat on their land. In another, a fence that neighbors wanted a couple to help pay for turned out to stand six inches inside the neighbors’ lot.

For now, the account rests on the homeowner’s own measurements and belief. No survey has been reported, and the neighbor’s side comes only through his telling.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: Shixart1985 – CC BY 2.0/Wikimedia Commons

Similar Posts