A Driver Crashed Through Dave Osborne’s Front-Yard Fence in Roy Overnight, the Second Time It’s Happened in Less Than 14 Months
Dave Osborne and his wife got home from Las Vegas, went to sleep in their basement and never heard a thing. Early Saturday morning, a Roy police officer left a voicemail with the news: someone had taken out the front part of the white fence.
It was the second time in less than 14 months that a driver had crashed through the same front-yard fence in Roy, Utah, according to KSL’s report published Nov. 14. The home sits near 4800 South and 2950 West, close to a roundabout.
Tire Marks, Debris and Pieces of Fence
When Osborne walked outside, the yard told the story. KSL reported that he found tire marks, debris from the vehicle and sections of fence scattered across the lawn.
The vehicle had come close to doing much worse. It missed a shed, a tree, a fire hydrant and a nearby home. Police have not said whether anyone was hurt in the overnight crash, and the Roy Police Department had not responded to KSL’s requests for details.
“Yes, it’s very frustrating,” Osborne told the station.
The First Crash Was Worse
The fence had been hit before. In September 2025, KSL reported, a driver struck the same fence and also hit a woman, who was taken to a hospital. That driver left the scene and later turned himself in.
Now Osborne is back where he was a year ago. He told KSL he needs to “get some quotes to have some fence cleanup done,” and then a new fence.
For a homeowner, the cost question usually comes down to insurance and to whoever was behind the wheel. In Utah, the state’s Insurance Department oversees insurers, posts information on home claims and takes consumer complaints when a problem with an insurer or agent cannot be resolved directly. It can be reached at (801) 957-9200 or toll-free at (800) 439-3805.
A Roundabout Next Door
The crashes happened near a roundabout, a type of intersection federal safety officials favor. The Federal Highway Administration’s roundabouts page calls them a Proven Safety Countermeasure that can “substantially reduce crashes that result in serious injury or death,” partly because they slow traffic and cut down the points where vehicles can collide.
The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety’s roundabout research puts numbers on that. When U.S. intersections were converted from signals or stop signs to roundabouts, injury crashes fell 72% to 80% and all crashes fell 35% to 47%, according to IIHS. Entering vehicles in urban roundabouts slow to roughly 15 to 20 mph.
The gains can take time to show up. IIHS says earlier U.S. studies of two-lane roundabouts found smaller reductions, or even more crashes, and that a 2019 study of roundabouts in Washington state found crashes at two-lane designs dropped about 9% a year on average as drivers got used to them. At higher-speed rural intersections of 40 mph or more, conversions cut all crashes by 62% and injury crashes by 85%.
Those averages are little comfort to the one house where drivers keep leaving the road. KSL’s report does not say how either driver lost control, or whether the roundabout played a part.
Taking It to City Hall
Osborne said his next move is to go higher. “That’s my next step is to go to the police chief or the city council,” he told KSL.
Roy City lists its Municipal Center at 5051 S 1900 W, with a main line at 801-774-1000, and the city’s site links to City Council agendas and minutes for residents who want to raise an issue in public. Non-emergency police dispatch is 801-395-8221.
For now, the Osbornes have a front yard full of broken fence, another round of repair quotes ahead and the same question they had last fall: how to keep the next car out of their yard.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: inkknife_2000 – CC BY-SA 2.0/Wikimedia Commons
