Runoff From a Construction Site Washed Out Jaylene Moss’s Fences and Broke a Pipe Under the Front Yard. An Appeals Court Says Concord Can’t Claim Immunity.
Several feet of brown water poured off a construction site and onto Jaylene Moss’s Concord, North Carolina, property in 2019, according to the lawsuit she and her company later filed. When it drained, sections of one fence were gone, another fence was destroyed and a stormwater pipe under the front yard had broken open into a hole about 2 feet by 2 feet.
Concord argued it could not be sued over the flooding. On Nov. 18, the North Carolina Court of Appeals disagreed.
What the Property Owners Say Happened
Moss and RWJ Consulting, the company that owns the property and that she leads, sued the city in 2022, the Carolina Journal reported. They blame a city-approved residential development next door.
The complaint says the 2019 flood “swamped Plaintiffs’ property with several feet of brown water from the construction site.” It left debris and trash behind, washed away sections of the north fence, destroyed the south fence and broke the pipe beneath the front yard. The owners say more flooding followed from 2020 through 2024.
They brought claims for negligence, trespass and private nuisance, along with inverse condemnation, which argues the government effectively took private property without paying for it. None of their allegations has been decided at trial.
The Ruling: Stormwater Is a Business-Like Service
A trial judge refused to throw out the case in June 2025, and Concord appealed. In Moss v. City of Concord, No. 26-82, filed Nov. 18, Judge Julee Flood wrote for a unanimous three-judge panel affirming the trial court. Judges Allegra Collins and Jeff Carpenter joined her.
The key finding was that managing stormwater is a proprietary function for Concord, not a governmental one, so the city does not get governmental immunity from the negligence, trespass and nuisance claims. The opinion is unpublished, which limits its weight as precedent.
That line matters in North Carolina. Cities are generally shielded from negligence suits over governmental functions done for the public good, but not over proprietary ones, which courts describe as chiefly for the advantage of the local community, explains a UNC School of Government analysis by Rebecca L. Fisher-Gabbard. Courts look at how the legislature labels the activity, whether only government could do it, and factors such as whether a substantial fee is charged.
Concord Runs Stormwater on Fees
Concord’s stormwater program is funded mainly through stormwater utility fees, with an annual budget of roughly $5 million to $7 million and about 21 full-time-equivalent staff, according to the city’s stormwater management plan filed with the state Department of Environmental Quality. The plan lists construction site runoff control among the program’s required areas.
Fee-funded stormwater programs are common across the state. A UNC Environmental Finance Center survey of 101 North Carolina stormwater utilities found a median residential fee of $5 a month.
What Happens Next
The ruling does not decide whether Concord is responsible for the damage. It sends the negligence, trespass and nuisance claims back to the trial court, where Moss and her company still have to prove them.
Runoff from new building next door has become a familiar yard complaint, from San Antonio’s southeast side, where a water main project has swamped yards two summers running, to a Brownsville backyard that floods every long rain.
For the Concord property, the fight over broken fences and a hole in the front yard now heads back to the courtroom where it started.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
