A street scene in the coastal town of Ogunquit, Maine

A Maine Family Paid $1,700 in Fines Over the Tin Roosters in Their Front Yard, Put There for Their 6-Year-Old Daughter With Autism, and Now They’re Suing Ogunquit

In the front yard of the LeBlanc family’s home in Ogunquit, Maine, one tin rooster still stands, hidden under a cover. It is the last of the birds that once lined the yard for 6-year-old Pyper, who has autism and loves roosters. After $1,700 in town fines, her parents, Dave and Sara LeBlanc, have filed a federal lawsuit against the town, WMTW reported in a story carried by CNN Newsource.

The town says the roosters are unpermitted signs for the family’s breakfast restaurant, which is attached to the house. The family says they are a gift for their daughter, and that treating them as advertising violates their free speech rights.

A 6-Foot Rooster for Pyper

The LeBlancs first put a 6-foot-tall tin rooster in front of their home in May 2025. Pyper has a special interest in roosters, and her parents say the statues comfort her and help her on the way to and from school, according to WGME.

Over time the family acquired about two dozen tin roosters. Their lawsuit says they never displayed more than eight at once on the property, except during the Christmas season.

Dave LeBlanc told WGME the roosters stand for the family’s love for their daughter, and that the town “made up an entirely different meaning for them.”

Why Ogunquit Calls Them Signs

The family’s home is attached to The Omelette Factory, the breakfast restaurant they own. Town officials view the roosters as advertising for the business that goes past the size limits in the town’s sign code, WGME reported.

The family disputes that. According to their complaint, most of the roosters carry no words, logos or references to the restaurant. The rooster does appear on the restaurant’s menu and merchandise, which the family describes as a show of support for Pyper.

The complaint, filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Maine, lays out how the fines added up in 2026:

  • April 3: a violation letter ordering removal of “unpermitted signage,” including the roosters
  • April 6: a $150 fine
  • April 16: a $300 fine
  • June 24: a $500 fine
  • Sept. 17: a $750 penalty

That comes to $1,700, all of which the family says it paid under protest.

A Variance That Needed a Railing the House Doesn’t Have

The family took the fight to the town’s Zoning Board of Appeals. At a June 11, 2026, hearing, the board agreed that the roosters count as signs, according to the complaint. It did grant a disability variance allowing two roosters on the residential side of the building, but only if they were built into a railing attached to the house.

The LeBlancs say the home has no such railing. The June fine was for not building one, and the September penalty was for failing either to remove the roosters or to fix them to a railing.

The complaint also says the town did not respond when the family asked how to comply, and that the town has not enforced the same rules against other people in Ogunquit who display tin roosters. It counts at least 14 homes and businesses in town that do.

Neighbors, a Farm Store and a Covered Rooster

The roosters that once stood in the LeBlancs’ yard have not disappeared. The family gave them to friends and neighbors, who now display them in support of Pyper. The complaint says at least nine of the family’s roosters are on display elsewhere.

Support came from a store, too. In October, the Sanford Tractor Supply gave Pyper a custom-made tin rooster in her favorite colors with her name on it, WGME reported. Store manager Trent Smith said Pyper had been “an inspiration to so many” and the store wanted her to have a rooster of her very own.

Sara LeBlanc told WGME that Pyper lights up when she sees other roosters around town. She told WMTW it has been a range of emotions for her daughter, who has asked why the town can’t simply be nice.

The Lawsuit’s Free Speech Claims

The family is represented by Daniel Woislaw and Griffin Brunk of the Institute for Justice, a national public interest law firm, along with Portland attorney Benjamin Hartwell. The firm had already warned the town in writing in early October that a code officer could not treat a rooster as decoration in one yard and as illegal in another, WGME reported at the time.

The suit makes two claims. It argues the town’s enforcement violates the First Amendment, and that the sign code is so vague it is unconstitutional under the First and 14th Amendments. It asks the court to bar the town from fining or prosecuting the family over the roosters, and seeks damages that include repayment of the fines.

“It’s not neutral. It’s not even-handed. It’s uneven, unfair and arbitrary,” Woislaw told WMTW. Brunk, in WGME’s report, called the enforcement “textbook speaker-based discrimination,” arguing the town is regulating the family rather than the roosters.

A town official told WGME that Ogunquit does not comment on legal matters. For now, the one rooster left in the LeBlancs’ front yard stays where it is, under its cover, which the family told WGME is a sign it is not backing down.

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Image: dconvertini – CC BY-SA 2.0/Wikimedia Commons

Similar Posts